On 17 November 2026, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) published its bathing water classifications for summer 2027, and four of Scotland's 90 designated beaches failed. Portobello (West) in Edinburgh, Kinghorn (Harbour Beach) and Lower Largo in Fife, and Dunbar (East) in East Lothian are rated Poor. At a Poor beach, SEPA's advice is that bathing is not advised.

Everywhere else clears the bar. SEPA's results release puts 44 beaches at Excellent, 30 at Good and 12 at Sufficient. That is a slight slip from a year ago, when the split for 2026, across 89 bathing waters, was 47 Excellent, 26 Good, 13 Sufficient and 3 Poor. This year's 90th is the newly designated Ballachulish Peninsula in the Highlands, rated Good in its first classification.

All four failures are on the east coast, in Fife, Edinburgh and East Lothian. So are some of Scotland's most consistent Excellent beaches, which is where this piece ends up.

What a Poor rating means for a swim in summer 2027

Each classification is built from four seasons of samples, in this case 2023 to 2026, and holds for the whole of the following season. The samples are tested for two gut bacteria, E. coli and intestinal enterococci. In SEPA's definitions, Excellent meets the highest standard and Good a high one, Sufficient meets the minimum required standard, and Poor falls below it.

A rating is a long-run average, not a daily promise. Even at an Excellent beach, SEPA advises against bathing during heavy rain and for one to two days after it, when run-off and sewer overflows can carry pollution into the sea. There is no Blue Flag to fall back on either: according to Marine Scotland, the programme in Scotland was discontinued at the end of 2016 (our Blue Flag explainer covers the awards that replaced it). SEPA's classification is the water-quality measure to look at.

The four Poor beaches failed for different reasons, and their chances of recovery differ too.

Kinghorn Harbour Beach loses its bathing water status

Kinghorn's harbour beach has now been rated Poor five years running. As SEPA's Kinghorn page explains, under the regulations that ends its designation: it becomes a former bathing water with permanent advice against bathing. SEPA stresses this is a legal requirement, not a choice.

The pollution is mainly human sewage, with birds and dogs adding to it, carried into the bay by the culverted Kinghorn Burn and its tributary, the Lady Burn. Extra sampling in 2026 found the water generally worse near the burn at the northern end, but some late-season samples were also high at the southern end, so walking to the far end is no safe bet.

SEPA is serving Scottish Water with a further regulatory notice, and it will lift the advice only once there is evidence of sustained improvement. Kinghorn's other designated beach, Pettycur, is a separate bathing water and is rated Good for 2027.

Is it safe to swim at Portobello beach? West is Poor, Central is Sufficient

Portobello is two bathing waters, and they have parted ways. Portobello (West) has dropped from Sufficient to Poor, while Portobello (Central), to its south-east, has held on at Sufficient. SEPA's source tracking at West points to a mix of sewage, dogs and gulls.

Fixes are under way. Scottish Water has found misconnections affecting almost 60 properties, where household sewage pipes were plumbed into rainwater drains, and its catchment investigation is due to finish by the end of 2026. A £1 million modelling study of the wider Portobello catchment is due to conclude in early 2027, to pick out infrastructure projects for future investment. The City of Edinburgh Council is tackling dog fouling, litter and gull feeding.

Both Portobello waters get SEPA's daily rain-based prediction, shown on an electronic sign at the beach. If you swim at Central in 2027, read the sign first.

Lower Largo and Dunbar (East): two different problems

Lower Largo has been Poor in every classification since it was designated in 2022, five in a row, so for 2027 bathing is not advised there. Unlike Kinghorn, it has not yet been given permanent advice against bathing. SEPA says that advice is required only if sufficient improvement in water quality is not demonstrated, and it is still testing whether recent work has brought that improvement. The village's wastewater treatment works discharges into the bay and, SEPA says, was never designed to bathing-water standards. During the 2026 season Scottish Water commissioned an on-site plant with biological treatment and UV disinfection, and SEPA is sampling outside the season to see whether it is working. If it isn't, permanent advice against bathing follows and Lower Largo stops being a designated bathing water. Checked November 2026.

Dunbar (East) is the surprise. It was Good or Excellent for years, slipped to Sufficient for the 2026 season (in the classification SEPA published in 2025) and is now Poor. Source tracking consistently points to gull droppings, and SEPA notes the beach has lost a lot of sand and gathered extensive seaweed. No fix has been found yet. Dunbar's other beach, Belhaven, is rated Good, and Whitesands, about 3km south-east of the town, is Excellent.

Fisherrow Sands is back to Sufficient

The good news is at Musselburgh. Fisherrow Sands in East Lothian, rated Poor for the 2025 and 2026 seasons, has climbed to Sufficient for 2027, which SEPA says means it now meets the required bathing water standard.

A curving sandy beach at Fisherrow Sands, Musselburgh, with dune grass in the foreground leading to a stone harbour wall and Musselburgh's seafront buildings in the distance, under a blue sky.
A curving sandy beach at Fisherrow Sands, Musselburgh, with dune grass in the foreground leading to a stone harbour wall and Musselburgh's seafront buildings in the distance, under a blue sky.

Sufficient is the minimum pass, so the rain rule matters more here than at the beaches below.

Excellent beaches near Edinburgh and in Fife for summer 2027

A broad sandy beach at low tide on Gullane Bay, with the sea on the left, marram-covered dunes on the right and a dark rocky ledge at the far end.
A broad sandy beach at low tide on Gullane Bay, with the sea on the left, marram-covered dunes on the right and a dark rocky ledge at the far end.

SEPA's region of Edinburgh, the Lothians and Borders has five Excellent beaches, and Fife has seven. These are the ones to plan around, taken from SEPA's full classification list:

  • Gullane, East Lothian: a large sandy bay about 2km long. SEPA's profile finds no significant pollution inputs in normal conditions, even after rainfall, and it has been Excellent in every classification since at least 2017.
  • Seacliff, East Lothian: Excellent for 2027 and in every SEPA classification since 2017 bar one, a Good rating published in November 2023 for the 2024 season.
  • Whitesands, East Lothian: a small, shallow, enclosed bay about 3km south-east of Dunbar, and the obvious swap for Dunbar (East).
  • Thorntonloch, East Lothian: Excellent in every classification since 2018.
  • Pease Bay, Scottish Borders: a 600m sandy bay about 1.6km east of Cockburnspath, popular with surfers.
  • Fife, Forth shore: Aberdour (Silversands), on the same shore as Kinghorn and about 7km west of it, beyond Burntisland.
  • Fife, East Neuk and St Andrews: Elie (Harbour) and Earlsferry, Elie (Ruby Bay), Anstruther (Billow Ness), Crail (Roome Bay), Kingsbarns and St Andrews (East Sands). Elie is the nearest of these to Lower Largo.

Closer to the city, Wardie Beach in Edinburgh and both North Berwick bathing waters are rated Good. For the west coast and the islands, see our guide to the best beaches in Scotland.

How to check SEPA's bathing water forecast before you swim

A good classification tells you where to go. The daily forecast tells you whether to go in. Before any swim in 2027:

  • Know the season. Scottish Ministers set the dates each year. In 2026 the season ran from 1 June to 15 September, the traditional window, and SEPA takes a pre-season sample in the last fortnight of May. The 2027 dates had not been announced by November 2026.
  • Check the prediction. SEPA's bathing water predictions page is updated by 10am daily from mid-May to 15 September for beaches where rain tends to affect the water, including both Portobello bathing waters.
  • Read the beach sign. At those beaches the electronic sign shows either "Water quality is forecast to be acceptable today" or a warning of poorer quality.
  • Look at the overflow map. SEPA's forecasts don't capture overflows caused by faults such as electrical failure, but Scottish Water's live overflow map shows near real-time data from monitored overflows.
  • Respect the rain rule. Stay out during heavy rain and for one to two days afterwards. SEPA's FAQ page stretches that to three.

Outside the season there is no daily forecast and no routine sampling, so winter dippers are left to their own judgement. Cold water and currents matter as much as clean water, and our guide to rip currents covers how to spot and escape one. Checked November 2026.

The plan for summer 2027 is simple. Skip the four Poor beaches, swim at Central rather than West if Portobello is your local, and choose Gullane, Whitesands or the East Neuk when you can travel.